Ruzora
Talent Strategy

Equity vs Cash for Engineers: How Much to Offer

Carta data puts the median first engineering hire at 1.5% equity, falling to about 0.33% by hire five. When to lead with equity, and when cash wins.

RE

CEO, Ruzora

Updated 7 min read

The median equity grant for a startup's first non-founder hire is 1.5%, dropping to about 0.85% for the second and roughly 0.33% by the fifth, per Carta's State of Seed data reported by SaaStr. Whether an engineer would rather have that equity or more cash depends on who they are, and for remote and nearshore hires cash usually wins.

Founders love to offer equity because it's cheap on the cash line. Engineers value it very differently depending on their situation, and getting the mix wrong costs you either runway or the hire. There's no universal answer here, and pretending there is loses people.

Key Takeaways

  • Preference is circumstantial: some engineers trade cash for upside, others need the cash (The Pragmatic Engineer).
  • Equity grants shrink fast by employee number: a median of roughly 1.5% for employee #1 to ~0.3% by #5 (SaaStr, citing Carta's State of Seed).
  • For most non-founding hires, equity is a long-shot bonus, not the deciding factor.
  • For remote and nearshore engineers, cash-forward comp usually wins, and flexible mixes win more.

Do Engineers Prefer Equity or Cash?

As The Pragmatic Engineer lays out, equity value depends entirely on circumstances: risk tolerance, financial situation, and belief in the company. Early employees take more risk and typically accept below-market cash for more equity. And grants drop quickly with each hire: SaaStr, citing Carta's State of Seed data, reports a median first-hire grant of 1.5%, falling to about 0.33% by employee number five.

For most hires past the first handful, equity is a lottery ticket attached to the offer, not the reason they say yes.

How Much Equity Should the First Engineering Hires Get?

Median grants from Carta's seed-stage data, four-year vesting with a one-year cliff (SaaStr):

HireMedian grant25th–75th percentile
#11.50%0.50%–4.00%
#20.85%0.30%–2.00%
#30.50%0.20%–1.20%
#40.44%0.18%–1.00%
#50.33%0.13%–0.80%

The spread matters as much as the median. A first hire who is really a technical co-founder in all but title sits near the top of the range. A first hire joining a funded company with a working product sits near the bottom. Give away too much in the first ten hires and you'll be short when a VP of Engineering at Series A expects a real grant.

Should You Offer Equity to Remote or Nearshore Engineers?

Equity is hardest to value when the engineer is outside the US: unfamiliar tax treatment, currency risk, and a longer, hazier path to any liquidity event. A senior engineer in São Paulo or Lima usually weights cash far more heavily than a Bay Area hire who's seen exits happen. That's not a knock on equity; it's a reason to lead with competitive cash for these roles and treat equity as upside.

HireLikely preference
Founding / very early USEquity-heavy, accepts lower cash
Mid-stage USBalanced, equity as upside
Remote / nearshore seniorCash-forward, equity as bonus

This is one reason staff augmentation is clean: it's a straightforward cash arrangement with no equity to value, and the flat, all-in rate is unambiguous.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do engineers prefer equity or cash?

It depends on the individual. Early US employees often take equity over cash; most later and remote hires weight cash more heavily. There's no universal answer.

How much equity do early employees get?

Per Carta's State of Seed data (via SaaStr), a median of roughly 1.5% for the first employee, falling to about 0.33% by employee number five. It shrinks fast as the company grows.

Is 1% equity good for a first engineer?

It's a bit below the 1.5% median for hire #1 in Carta's seed data, and well inside the 0.5% to 4% middle range. Whether it's fair depends on the cash salary, the stage, and how much risk the engineer is taking on.

Should I offer equity to remote or nearshore engineers?

You can, but lead with competitive cash. Equity is harder to value across borders (tax, currency, liquidity), so most weight it lightly. Treat it as upside.

The Bottom Line

Stop treating equity as a universal sweetener. Match the mix to the hire: equity-heavy for the earliest US believers, cash-forward for most others, and especially for remote and nearshore engineers who can't easily value a far-off, foreign-currency upside.

Want senior engineers without negotiating equity? See vetted senior LATAM engineers, or tell us the role and get a vetted shortlist within 72 hours.

Roberto Espinoza is CEO of Ruzora, which helps US startups hire pre-vetted senior LATAM engineers.

RE

CEO, Ruzora

Roberto is the founder and CEO of Ruzora. He works directly with US startup founders and CTOs on staff-augmentation and software-factory engagements, and personally reviews senior engineer placements.

Senior LATAM engineers

Get a vetted shortlist within 72 hours.

Tell us the role and the stack. Within 72 hours you're reviewing a vetted shortlist of senior LATAM engineers who match it.